feature story / 17
Peskin remembers being nervous 
before they met. Anderson was her 
first CASA case, though not her first 
experience mentoring youth. What 
she didn’t expect was how quickly 
the connection would feel genuine.
“She was engageable,” Peskin 
says. “We started having really great, 
honest conversations right away.”
For decades, Peskin had volun­
teered with young people through­
out New York City experiencing 
homelessness, incarceration and in­
stability. “What I was really drawn to 
[with CASA] was the opportunity to 
focus deeply on one child and build 
a relationship,” she says. 
Their conversations quickly moved 
beyond surface-level small talk into 
deeper discussions about race, trust, 
family and lived experience.
Anderson admits she initially felt 
uncertain opening up to a white ad­
vocate. “What if I tell you I’m hav­
ing a bad hair day?” Anderson jokes. 
“Are you going to understand that?”
Instead of avoiding those differ­
ences, they talked openly about them.
“I believe the only thing that will 
save this country is people getting to 
know each other across differences,” 
Peskin says. “Across racial difference, 
generation, socioeconomic difference. 
Let’s actually get to know each other.” 
Over time, trust grew. But not 
without resistance. “I pushed every­
body away,” Anderson says. “I just felt 
like, growing up in the system, people 
didn’t have my best interest in mind.” 
Peskin kept showing up, even 
when Anderson changed phone 
numbers, when life became chaotic 
and when it would have been easier 
to disappear.
“She always found a way to get 
in contact with me,” Anderson says. 
“That’s when I knew Joy was going 
to stick by my side forever.”
Peskin remembers one winter 
meeting at a diner in Newark just 
before Christmas. Temperatures had 
dropped below 10 degrees that day, 
yet Anderson arrived wearing only 
a tank top, sweatpants and slides. 
When Peskin asked whether she had 
a coat, Anderson admitted she could 
not afford one.
In her next court report, Peskin 
requested additional funds so An­
derson could purchase winter cloth­
ing. Initially, the request was denied 
by the Division of 
Child 
Protection 
and 
Permanency. 
But the judge inter­
vened and ordered 
the funds be pro­
vided.
“I can’t solve the 
foster care problem 
in this country,” Pe­
skin says. “But I can 
help get a coat for a 
teenager who’s cold 
in the winter. And 
that really matters.”
Peskin says that one of the most 
difficult parts of foster care for young 
people can be the court process itself. 
“You enter the system because adults 
failed you,” she says. “But over time, 
it can start to feel like you’re the one 
on trial.”
During court hearings, Peskin 
made a point to advocate not only for 
Anderson’s needs but for the judge 
to see her strengths as well. “I always 
tried to talk about the good things 
Courtney was doing,” Peskin says. “I 
wanted the court to see the promising 
young woman she already was.”
After becoming pregnant at 19, 
she bounced between shelters and 
temporary housing while trying to 
prepare for motherhood. But along­
side the instability was something 
else: determination.
“She doesn’t quit,” Peskin says. 
“When Courtney wants something, 
she commits.”
When Anderson applied for a 
highly competitive housing program 
for young mothers aging out of foster 
Courtney Anderson at her high school graduation.
The Jennifer McManus Team 
(917) 837-2192 
jennifer.mcmanus@cbmoves.com
SOLD – $2,800,000
229 Orange Rd, Montclair 
Listed Exclusively for $2,400,000
UNDER CONTRACT!
4 Kermit Rd, Maplewood 
Multiple over ask Bids
UNDER CONTRACT!
5 Highland Blvd, West Orange 
Multiple over ask Bids
SOLD!
9 Osborne Ter, Maplewood
SP: $1,825,000
SOLD!
59 Park Ave, Maplewood)
SP: $1,253,000
SOLD!
35 Broadview Ave, Maplewood 
SP: $931,000
UNDER CONTRACT!
63 Blanchard Rd, South Orange
Multiple over ask Bids
SOLD!
318 Metzger Dr, West Orange
Exclusive Sale: $979,000
The Jennifer McManus 
Team Has Been  
HARD AT WORK. 
Look at Some of Our  
MAY RESULTS! 
Let the  
Jennifer McManus 
Team get you MOVING.
Read what this client says about Jen:
“Jen’s knowledge of the market is deep, and she not only marketed our house, she marketed 
the neighborhood. It was great to navigate this experience confident that we were in good 
hands with a whip smart agent who has a great sense of humor and takes everything in stride.” 

View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.