12 / matters magazine / spring 2026
I
f you’ve ever been on Dogs of Soma or an­
other local Facebook group, you know that 
dogs and cats sometimes – OK, often – get 
loose. A kid or a contractor leaves the gate 
open. A couple of adventurous pups take 
themselves on a tour of the neighborhood. 
Sometimes a stray dog is seen wandering 
around for days or even weeks, prompting con­
cern from a kind neighbor. 
“Our dog escaped the backyard and is missing. 
If you see her, please call!” a post might read. Or, 
“I saw these dogs on my way home but didn’t have 
time to stop. Anyone know who they belong to?”
Read enough of these posts about lost or stray 
animals and you’ll see two people tagged over and 
over again: Kelly Conover and Marcia Sandford 
Fishkind. 
Conover and Sandford Fishkind will spring 
into action: gathering sightings, hopping in their 
cars for a stakeout, and setting traps, feeding sta­
tions and cameras. They work until a lost dog or 
cat is safely back home with their family. If they're 
stray dogs or cats, they will bring them to their 
house to decompress and get checked out before 
heading to a foster family or rescue and then, 
hopefully, a forever home. 
“We help people find their dogs … and we 
help dogs who have no people,” says Sandford 
Fishkind, who also helps trap and transport in­
jured foxes and rescues cats.
While South Orange and Maplewood contract 
Animal Control Solutions for animal control, the 
organization does not search for lost pets, accord­
ing to the towns’ websites.
Conover and Sandford Fishkind have had pets 
and helped pets their entire lives. Sandford Fish­
kind, who lives in Short Hills, is retired from her 
job at a tech company 
in sales and devotes 
most of her time 
to helping animals. 
Conover, who lives 
in South Orange, is a 
psychologist who fos­
tered pit bulls when 
she lived in the city. 
The duo met four 
years ago when they 
saw each other’s com­
ments trying to help 
a lost dog in the area. 
Local Duo Rescues 
Lost Pets
New nonprofit All Paws In helps fur babies find their way back home 
BY CINDY PERMAN
Clockwise from top left: Conover and Sandford Fishkind helped rescue Goldie, a goldendoodle, who was left in a crate in the snow in Irvington Park and adopted with the 
help of PAWS Montclair. Maya was found loose in Irvington. Conover and Sandford Fishkind arranged a foster for her. After the owner agreed to surrender Maya, she was 
adopted with the help of PAWS Montclair. “Amtrak Amy” was spotted by a NJ Transit engineer running around the tracks in Harrison. She is available for adoption through NJ 
Shetland Sheepdog Placement Services. Sandford Fishkind with Coconut, a Pomeranian mix, who was found running near a warehouse. He was rescued after two days and 
adopted by his foster family through Rosemarie’s Rescue Ranch. These kittens and their mom were rescued and are available for adoption. Photo by Julia Maloof Verderosa. 
Conover with one of the 
kittens she and Sandford 
Fishkind rescued.

View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.